DeFi · 3 min read

DeFi yields for Malaysians: where the returns come from and what can go wrong

Before chasing a DeFi yield, find out who is paying it. Where the returns come from, the risks behind them, and what Malaysian users give up off-exchange.

Decentralised finance — DeFi — offers yields that make a fixed deposit look sleepy. Before chasing one, ask the question every experienced user asks first: where does the return actually come from? If you cannot answer it, you are probably the return.

Where DeFi yield comes from

Lending interest

You deposit coins into a lending protocol and borrowers pay interest to use them, usually after posting collateral. Rates rise and fall with demand to borrow.

Trading fees

You supply a pair of tokens to a decentralised exchange’s liquidity pool and earn a share of the fees traders pay to swap between them.

Staking rewards

On proof-of-stake blockchains, coins committed to securing the network earn rewards. Staking through a third-party protocol adds that protocol’s risks on top.

Token incentives

Many protocols pay extra rewards in their own newly issued tokens to attract deposits. These headline yields are often the highest — and the least durable, because they depend on the token keeping its price.

What can go wrong

  • Smart-contract failures. Code can contain bugs, and exploits drain protocols regularly. An audit reduces the risk; it does not remove it.
  • Bridge hacks. Moving tokens between blockchains relies on bridges, which have been among the largest targets of theft.
  • Stablecoin de-pegs. A “stable” coin can lose its peg, taking the value of your deposit and your collateral with it.
  • Impermanent loss. In a liquidity pool, when one token’s price moves sharply you can end up with less value than if you had simply held both tokens.
  • Liquidation. If you borrow and the market moves against your collateral, it can be sold automatically at a loss.
  • Admin keys and rug pulls. Some protocols can be changed or emptied by the people who control them.

The Malaysian access reality

DeFi protocols are not registered with the Securities Commission. Using one means moving coins off a registered exchange into your own wallet and dealing directly with code and counterparties overseas. If something goes wrong there is no local regulator, no ombudsman and usually no one to call. Registered exchanges also ask questions about withdrawals to outside wallets under anti-money-laundering rules; expect them.

Two more Malaysian considerations. Rewards can be income for tax purposes, depending on the facts — see how LHDN approaches crypto income. And interest-based lending raises Shariah concerns that the SC’s resolution on trading digital assets does not address; we explain the difference in is crypto halal?

Questions to answer before you deposit

  1. Who pays the yield, and why would they keep paying it?
  2. How much of the rate is paid in the protocol’s own token?
  3. How long has the protocol run, how much does it hold, and has it been audited — and exploited?
  4. Can you withdraw at any time, or is there a lock-up?
  5. What happens to your deposit if the stablecoin or token involved loses half its value overnight?

If the answers are vague, the risk is not. Only commit money you could lose entirely, and never money borrowed to chase a yield.